Activated Charcoal vs Baking Soda for Odors: Which Fits a Litter Box?
Activated charcoal vs baking soda for odors comes down to how each one works: baking soda reacts with acids, while activated charcoal holds gas molecules on its surface. For your litter box, choose Purrify and mix it into the litter you already use.
Purrify TeamUpdated November 15, 202612 min read
8.3 - the pH of a freshly made baking soda solution, says PubChem (NIH). So it's a "base": a base reacts with acids, but ammonia is not an acid.
8.3Baking soda
11.1Ammonia
0Acid7Neutral14Base
Baking soda and ammonia both sit on the base side of neutral, so baking soda has nothing to react with in ammonia. pH of 0.1 molar solutions in water, from PubChem (NIH).13
70%less odor in a food-waste bin with 50 g of baking soda, but litter box odor is not like food odor.
1,100 m²of internal surface in each gram of Purrify's coconut-shell carbon, all holding onto odor molecules
2 to 4the pH range industrial farm ammonia scrubbers use for acid, because acid is what catches ammonia.
Purrify granules mixed into the litter you already use trap odors.
Different jobs
Activated charcoal vs baking soda for odors comes down to how each one works: baking soda reacts with acids,2 while activated charcoal holds gas molecules on its surface.9 For your litter box, choose Purrify and mix it into the litter you already use.
That is why fridge advice uses both. Wash the inside with baking soda and keep an open box on the shelf,14 then use activated charcoal if the odor persists.13 A fridge and a litter box do not smell of the same things, though, and fridge advice does not tell us what happens in litter.
For the litter box, the answer is still activated carbon. Cat urine gives off sulfur compounds,78 and a lab study found that carbon holds methyl mercaptan, a sulfur odor compound.11 We found no study that measured litter smell with baking soda. A carbon air filter cleans room air. Purrify is activated carbon in granules you mix into the litter you already use, and it is the most powerful odor remover in the world.
Evidence scaleNo evidenceIndirectPartialMeasured
They do different jobs: baking soda reacts with acids,1 and activated carbon holds gas molecules on its surface.9
Baking soda earns its place in the fridge, not the litter box: in a preliminary study, “50 g of baking soda, spread at the bottom of 8l food wastes bin, can reduce the odour by about 70%.” That was food waste, not litter.5
More baking soda can backfire: the same authors advise against going above 100 g, because a pH above 9.0 may release odorous ammonia.5
Ammonia and baking soda are both bases: ammonia is “A colorless alkaline gas”,3 baking soda “is a weak base”.1 We found no source showing baking soda neutralizes ammonia.
Carbon holds sulfur odor compounds: a lab study on methyl mercaptan reported “relatively high capacities of carbons” for removing it.11
Fridge advice agrees on carbon also: wash with baking soda and keep an open box inside,14 and if the odor persists, use activated charcoal.13
01
Is charcoal or baking soda better for odors?
Coconut shells: great cat toy, even better odor carbon.Which one, and where+
FridgeWash the inside with baking soda in warm water, then keep an open box inside once the odor is down.14 If the odor still persists, Texas A&M AgriLife Extension says to use activated charcoal.13
Food-waste binBaking soda. About 70% less odor at 50 g, in a preliminary study of food waste stored seven days.5
Room airAn activated carbon filter. The EPA says: “To filter gases, choose a portable air cleaner with an activated carbon filter or other filter designed to remove gases.”12
Litter boxActivated carbon. We found no study that measured litter-box smell with baking soda.
Baking soda is a good kitchen tool but the litter box is a different job, and the next sections show why.
02
How baking soda works on smells
Baking soda is sodium bicarbonate. PubChem lists the pH of a freshly made 0.1 molar solution at 8.3 and says “The solution in water is a weak base.”1 The American Chemical Society explains the same acid-base reaction: acid meets bicarbonate, and the pair turns into carbon dioxide and water.2
PubChem puts the fizz this way: “SODIUM BICARBONATE reacts exothermically with acids to generate non-toxic carbon dioxide gas.”1 Sour smells are acidic, so a base has something to react with.
How basic baking soda is
8.3pH of a freshly made 0.1 molar baking soda solution. A weak base, perfect to react with weak acids. (not litter smells, which are base)
The best evidence for baking soda against smell is food waste. Researchers at Universiti Sains Malaysia reported that “50 g of baking soda, spread at the bottom of 8l food wastes bin, can reduce the odour by about 70%.”5 The doses were per kilogram of food waste, stored seven days, and the authors called the work preliminary. It is a fair win for baking soda, on food waste.
White baking soda crystals beside porous black carbon, enlarged to show the difference in texture.
03
Does baking soda neutralize ammonia?
Two bases, one acid+
Ammonia“A colorless alkaline gas.” In water it behaves as a base.3
Baking sodaA weak base, pH 8.3 in a freshly made 0.1 molar solution.1
Barn air scrubbersWater kept at pH 2 to 4 with acid. “Acid scrubbers typically use sulfuric acid”, which turns ammonia into “(NH4)2SO4 (ammonium sulfate)”.4
The food-waste authors advise against “A higher amount (above 100g)” of baking soda “as a pH higher than 9.0 may be induced leading to the volatilization of odorous ammonia.”5 Past a point, they say more baking soda may raise the pH enough to send more ammonia into the air.
Where the authors say baking soda backfires
pH 9Above this level, the food-waste authors warn, odorous ammonia may be released.
As for where the ammonia comes from, a study of pig and cattle manure found that “Ammonia is formed in manure by the enzymatic degradation of urinary urea and catalyzed by urease that is present in feces.”6 Not a cat study, but the same urea-to-ammonia path. Urine and feces sit together in a litter box, so the same chemistry applies.
The old-fashioned fix works fairly well, if you do it fast:
Scoop urine clumps every day, so the urea leaves the box before it can turn into ammonia.
An EPA citizen's guide describes the same thing for activated carbon granules: “chemicals sorb or stick to the surface and within the pores of the granules.”10 The molecule sticks to the surface or settles inside a pore.
An illustration of the pores inside activated carbon, greatly enlarged. Odor molecules settle on and in these walls.
Sulfur smells are carbon's home ground. Methyl mercaptan is a sulfur odor compound, a thiol, and a lab study at City College of New York reported “relatively high capacities of carbons for removal of CH3SH.”11 The catty-urine odorant is a sulfur compound from the same family.78 And for whole rooms, the EPA recommends activated carbon filters to remove gases from the air.12
Inside one gram of Purrify's carbon
1,100 m²of internal surface per gram of coconut-shell carbon.
Purrify's data sheet.
How big is that? A Large bag of Purrify holds about 132,000 square meters of internal surface. By our math, with an American football field and its end zones covering 5,351 square meters, that's nearly 25 football fields, folded into pieces you can hold in your hand.
What happens with both litter-box smells
Acid
MMB
Baking sodaSodium bicarbonate, a weak base
1 of 2
Sour acidsNeutralized: CO₂ + water
Catty sulfurNo reaction found
Acid
MMB
Activated carbonCoconut shell, full of pores
2 of 2
Sour acidsHeld in a pore
Catty sulfurHeld in a pore
Baking soda, Sour acids: Neutralized: CO₂ + water
Baking soda, Catty sulfur: No reaction found
Activated carbon, Sour acids: Held in a pore
Activated carbon, Catty sulfur: Held in a pore
Baking soda reacts with acids, giving off carbon dioxide and water.1 Activated carbon holds gas molecules on its surface,9 sulfur odor compounds included.11
The ammonia smell comes from urea in urine, broken down by urease.6 Purrify traps it in the litter, and daily scooping removes its source.
The catty smell is something else. Researchers note that “Domestic cats spray urine with species-specific odor for territorial marking,” and in the air above cat urine they identified 3-mercapto-3-methyl-1-butanol and related sulfur compounds “as candidates for felinine derivatives.”7 A 2025 veterinary study agrees: normal cat urine “emits odorants with catty odor, such as 3-mercapto-3-methyl-1-butanol,” and “Felinine, an amino acid, is a precursor of these odorants.”8
Felinine is higher in males than in females, so a household with a tomcat may notice the catty smell more.7
Claim / what was measuredEvidence
Baking soda neutralizes acidsChemistry reference: reacts with acids to give carbon dioxide (PubChem)Measured
Baking soda neutralizes ammoniaBoth are bases, and no source shows it doesNo evidence
Baking soda stops litter smellNo study of litter-box smell foundNo evidence
Activated carbon holds sulfur odor compoundsLab study on methyl mercaptan, a sulfur compound (City College of New York)Measured
06
Which should you use in the litter box?
Keep the litter your cat likes.
Purrify works with every litter, including clay, clumping, crystal, tofu, pine and walnut, and it does not interfere with clumping or scooping.
2 tablespoons of Purrify per litter change.
Sprinkle on fresh litter, mix gently.
Sprinkle some more whenever the box starts to smell again.
For most homes the Large bag is the one to start with. It lasts about 30 days for one or two cats, per litter box.
Purrify granules going onto fresh litter, ready to be mixed in gently.
Baking soda can be a safety question as well as a smell question for some cats. Cats that eat a large amount can be poisoned. The details are in is baking soda safe for cats.
A note about usPurrify sells activated carbon, so for the chemistry on this page we cite only outside sources. The one figure from us, the 1,100 square meters per gram, comes from our supplier's data sheet and describes the material. How we handle claims: our editorial policy and testing policy.
How to use Purrify in your litter box
1
Scoop clumps every day
Ammonia forms as urea in urine breaks down, so removing the clumps early takes it out of the box.
2
Sprinkle Purrify on fresh litter
2 tablespoons of Purrify per litter box. Sprinkle on fresh litter, mix gently. Top up whenever the box starts to smell again.
3
Keep the litter you already use
Purrify works with clay, clumping, crystal, tofu, pine and walnut litter, and it does not interfere with clumping or scooping.
4
Keep baking soda for the fridge
Wash the inside of the fridge with it, then leave an open box on the shelf.
Common questions
Which is better for odors, charcoal or baking soda?
Neither wins everywhere. Baking soda reacts with acids, so it suits sour smells like spoiled food, and a food-waste study found about 70% less odor with 50 g of it. Activated charcoal holds odor molecules on its surface and inside its pores, so it suits sulfur compounds and gases in room air. In the litter box the catty smell is sulfur compounds, which is why activated carbon is the answer there.
Is baking soda or charcoal better for a smelly fridge?
Both, in order. NC State Extension says to wash with baking soda in warm water and then keep an open box of baking soda inside once the odor is down. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension says that if the odor still persists, use activated charcoal.
Does baking soda neutralize ammonia?
We found no source showing it does. Ammonia is a base and baking soda is a weak base, and barn systems catch ammonia with acid kept at pH 2 to 4. In a food-waste study, the authors warn that more than 100 g may push the pH above 9.0 and release odorous ammonia.
Does baking soda work in a litter box?
We found no study that measured litter-box smell with baking soda. Its best-documented odor result is on food waste, which is a different smell. Baking soda is also a safety question for cats that eat it, and our article on whether baking soda is safe for cats covers that.
Why does my litter box smell catty?
Cat urine gives off sulfur compounds such as 3-mercapto-3-methyl-1-butanol, which come from an amino acid called felinine. Felinine is higher in males than in females. A lab study found that activated carbon holds methyl mercaptan, a sulfur odor compound from the same family.
What should I use in the litter box, and how much?
Use Purrify. 2 tablespoons of Purrify per litter box. Sprinkle on fresh litter, mix gently. Top up whenever the box starts to smell again. Keep your usual litter and keep scooping every day. For most homes the Large bag is the one to start with, and it lasts about 30 days for one or two cats, per litter box.